Mehgan Machacynski said:
The best pies!!!! So many delicious flavours!
*and* monthly specials! (in case you needed more reason to visit again ;) Thanks Mehgan
Suzette Lacroix said:
My Go To Place
This is my go to place for all my holiday occassions. Always a FIVE STAR
That's so awesome to hear, Suzette!! Much appreciated :)
Lilian Yuen said:
Love this pie!
We order this pie every thanksgiving and christmas! It’s everything that’s great stuffed into a pie. We usually make a little gravy to go with it as well.
Awesome! Let the tradition continue :) Thank Lilian
Natalie M said:
We tried four of their pies. All were delicious. The crust was amazing. We had the holiday dinner pies, one with turkey and one vegan. Both were excellent. I’m not a fan of cranberry so my only minor dislike was that it had cranberry sauce in it. I just wish there was an option for cranberry on the side or not at all. I understand some people like it, but it’s a heavy flavour. But I still enjoyed the pie. Our pie had lots of turkey in it. Much more than I expected in a pie. All the vegans loved the vegan pie. We also tried the tortiere and the crust was perfect. The filling was pretty good and finally we had the berry crumble and there were no left overs. Great with ice cream.
Awesome! Glad they were all well received, Natalie :)
Tracy Sullivan said:
We recently ordered two Turkey Dinner 5"pies online. This process was very quick easy! We popped in a day before they were due to be ready for pick up and they had just baked them for us so we were able to get them early! Note: they can't do this with cream pies. The service-as always- was extremely friendly and accommodating. The pies were perfect-filled with all the goodness of a Turkey meal wrapped in a buttery, delicate pastry. Delicious! They look small but one was enough to share with one other person. Instructions were printed on the box for reheating. Can't recommend this company enough!
Awesome! Thanks so much Tracy :)
Janet U. said:
Turkey Dinner Pie
The turkey dinner pie overall has amazing flavour, although could use a little more cranberry sauce for my tastes! Interesting though, the actual turkey is more like very finely pulled pork in texture, as opposed to slow roasted turkey chunks. I’m not a pulled pork fan…but enjoyed everything on top of the turkey fibres!!
Thanks for the feedback, Janet. Glad you liked the taste :)
Jennifer Taylor said:
Not quite 5 star.
I was so looking forward to this pie for Xmas dinner. I’ve loved every other pie I’ve ever had from The Pie Hole. The Turkey Dinner Pie did not contain any actual pieces of Turkey. The Turkey meat was shredded so fine that it was almost like fabric. Very disappointing. I loved the taste and consistency of the mashed potatoes, gravy, and the stuffing was beautifully seasoned, tasting the sage, etc. There could have been more cranberry to balance everything out. I’m hoping that the chef reads these reviews and is able to make the changes people are sharing. Thanks!
Sounds like you liked the pie, overall. That's great! Sorry the pieces of turkey were smaller than you expected. As you hoped, feedback like yours is shared with the cooks so they can make any necessary adjustments next time around. Thanks for the review :)
F W said:
Great replacement for a traditional turkey dinner
Very good. Could have used a bit more cranberry sauce and the turkey could have been distributed more evenly, but in any case very delicious. Pie crust was great except one part that was undercooked. Our family is considering ordering this in lieu of making a full turkey dinner at Christmases from now on.
So glad to hear it, FW! I guess you now have a good idea of the ratio-tweaks you might want to make before digging in. Look forward to making it even better for you guys next time around :) Thanks for the review.
The EASIEST turkey dinner EVER
This was the easiest "complete turkey dinner". All of the components were present with minimal effort and none of the dreaded turkey leftovers which last for weeks on end...Even my 85 year old mother remarked about the excellent crust. Yeah!
Perfect! No mess, no endless leftovers, and a happy fam. Thanks for the review Chris :)
Mette Bach said:
We loved it! Thanks so much.
No problemo, Mette :) Happy Holidays
ian malcolm said:
I haven’t had the turkey pie yet ( cooking it on Xmas ) but I did buy a butter pecan pie and it was delicious. I’ll defend be going back.
Excellent. Fingers crossed it was a hit! Thanks Ian :)
Denise Kam said:
The bourbon pecan pie is one our favorites and we buy it every year for our neighbors for Christmas. Always a huge hit!
Nice! I am sure they very much appreciate it. Thanks Denise :)
John Smith said:
Love their Turkey pies! We buy them every Christmas. We even buy fir our friends. Takes the mess out of the kitchen. Worth every penny.
I don't know if 'fir' was a typo, but...well done ;) Appreciate the review John!
Jerry Wasserman said:
Turkey Dinner Pie is, miraculously, just what it says — a [w]hole pie containing an entire turkey dinner. And is it ever delish. Serves 4 for a whole lot less money than a turkey dinner with separate sides (mashed potatoes, stuffing, gravy, cranberry sauce). Mmmmm.
haha beauty! Thanks so much for the review, Jerry. So glad you guys liked it :)
Kathleen Gallagher said:
I received my pies they look so good. I cannot wait to try them. They are in the freezer waiting the next family gathering. So glad there are vegan choices for those who follow a pla lot based diet
That's some smart planning, Kathleen. Your next guests will appreciate it, I'm sure :) Thanks for the review.
Delicious as always
Even my grandmother's pie cannot compare! Their famous crust is always absolutely fantastic. This is my favorite pie from them and it really is a whole Thanksgiving dinner in one meal. Or any holiday where you enjoy savory turkey delicious mash and all the wonderful Sweet and savory seasonings.
*gasp* someone cover meemaw's ears! Thank you very much for the compliment, Vee :)
Alexi Stefanucci said:
First time ordering from the Pie Hole. I ordered a frozen pie for Christmas and picked up a Vegan Chocolate pie that was sooo yummy! Best ever. Will now add that to our Christmas dinner. Fantastic customer service as well. Looks like I have discovered a gem!!
That's so great to hear, Alexi! Helping you find pies you didn't even know you were missing :) Thanks for the review.
Amanda Sittrop said:
One of the greatest pies ever!
I tried the turkey pie many years ago and decided this was the year we needed to have it for Thanksgiving. It was the perfect choice for our family dinner of four. We also got the assorted sweet mini pies as dessert. Highly recommend as an easy delicious meal for small groups who want the taste of turkey dinner but don’t want the hassle of all that prep!
Absolutely! Tastiest time saver there ever was. Thanks so much Amanda :)
Leanne MacDougall said:
Best gift ever -- so thankful!
I have bought pies from the Pie Hole for my mom before and she has loved them. She wasn't feeling well over Thanksgiving so she missed the holiday meal. I thought sending her one of your Thanksgiving Dinner pies might help, and at least give her a taste of the holiday fixings. She loved it more than the last pie I had sent her, which I didn't think was possible. Once again, the Pie Hole hits it out of the park. So thankful!
That was like a mini Hallmark movie in my head. So thank YOU, Leanne :)
K. Moreland said:
Turkey Dinner Pie
Lovely pot pie, very moist, lots of turkey, will definitely order this again!
Thanks Katherine! Glad you liked it :)
Barbara MacDougall said:
My daughter ordered this for me because I was ill and missed Thanksgiving dinner. I had picked up a dinner locally but my favourites, dark meat, dressing and gravy were all missing. When I bit into this pie and found delicious dressing and scrumptious dark meat and potatoes, my craving was satisfied.
Maybe a bit more gravy but it was so delicious anyway. I definitely will buy again and my daughter who lives in Maryland is very eager to come and try your pies now.
Aw that's so great! We'll be your first stop when she visits ;) Thanks so much for the review, Barbara.
We had the turkey dinner pie as part of our Thanksgiving dinner and it was a big hit with all of the family from young to old!
Yay! Satisfaction all around the table! Thanks Rob :)
Deborah Skreslet said:
Wanted to love it
Ordered the turkey dinner pie for Thanksgiving. Would’ve loved it, but there was way too much sage in it, and I couldn’t even eat a full piece. Taste was overwhelming. I recommend they cut the portion at least in half so that it doesn’t dominate the pie.
I'm really sorry you didn't love it Deborah. Obviously, spice/herb tolerance is a continuum so we just have to aim for the middle...and reviews like yours help us dial it in! The feedback is much appreciated :)
Joy Wang said:
Turkey dinner pie
I ordered the individual 5" pie and it was delicious. I had worried that I had not made gravy to go with it, but the filling was delicious and not dry at all. I would definitely order this again.
Perfect! Thanks so much for the review, Joy :)
Ida Taylor said:
Turkey Dinner Pie
We just had this with guests and everyone loved it! Would definitely buy it again!
Excellent! So glad you all got to enjoy it. Thanks Ida :)
Brian Miller said:
Great online ordering experience
The site is super easy to navigate, lots of options available, and tasty pies, too!
That's so great to hear, Brian! No fuss, no muss, just pie. This is the way. Thanks for the review.
Rachel Siu said:
Turkey Dinner Pie
Absolutely stuffed with turkey. The pie was so attractive that the cat jumped onto the dinning table and she never does that.
Clearly, there is demand for a cat-sized Turkey Dinner out there. I must get to work...
Thanks Rachel :)
Mmm...can't talk with my mouth full!
I don't think words can properly convey the flavour and consistency of this delicious pie.
If you enjoy a traditional turkey dinner, I suggest you switch it up and try this delicious meal in a pie. A small (or large) slice of heaven in every bite! Nom nom!!!
A 'nom' is worth a thousand words :) Thanks so much Shell
Laurel Purghart said:
Turkey Dinner Pie
Second time ordering this delicious pie. The Pie Hole never disappoints!!!
We aim to please! Thanks so much Laurel :)
R & K said:
Turkey pie and apple rosemary
Yay! Thanks R&K :)
Judy Hamanishi said:
Best pie ever!
Sooooo delicious! My family of four (three of them very hearty male eaters) LOVED the turkey dinner pie. First time ever trying it but definitely not the last.
Maaaale eater, make you work hard, make you spend hard, make you want all of the pie ...I may be the only to enjoy that. I regret nothing. Judy you have brightened my day. Thank you so much :)
Patti Smith said:
Had two for Christmas dinner as we haven’t had a kitchen for 5 months now. We loved it and I ordered another for end of February for husbands birthday.
He loves all your pies. Thanks
Glad we can help you through your kitchenless times, Patti :) Appreciate the review.
Nola Brown said:
Turkey Dinner Delicious Pie!
Our family was excited to try this pie and it did not disappoint us. It was meaty and rich with a lovey herbaceous flavour. The crust was amazing and it did have all the flavours of turkey dinner! Five of us shared this pie and some really loved that there was not that much gravy, some tasted no cranberry and citrus while others seemed to get a piece of pie that had a dollop of that sauce inside. Some people loved the cranberry and citrus flavour but others found it overpowering. It was a lovely family dinner treat that turned out the way most of our family dinners do, which is to say that it is virtually impossible to please everyone. As the regular cook in our house, I found it scrumptious!
Thank you for creating this pie.
Yes! Excellent to hear, Nola! Each slice, and even each bite, of the Turkey Dinner Pie can be quite different AND, you are completely right, everyone has different tastes. Thanks for acknowledging that and I am so glad you guys liked it :)
Deborah DW said:
all the flavours at once
An absolutely perfect balance of all the dinner plate flavours.
I loved that there was both breast and leg meat combined with the gravy and cranberry
Awesome! Thanks so much Deborah :)
Donna L said:
Best turkey dinner
Love having turkey dinner in a pie! It hits all the flavours of a turkey dinner without all the work and carving.
You know it! More time for whatever turns your crank :) Thanks Donna.
Natalie Hyska said:
Christmas in January
This is my second turkey dinner pie. It is the best thing I’ve ever eaten. The turkey was SO GOOD I couldn’t believe it! Glad this time around I don’t have to share this pie ❤️
haha There are times for sharing and times for eating entire pies alone in front of the TV. We service all occasions ;P Thanks Natalie
Julie Marsden said:
Very Generous Savory Pie
Whether cooked from frozen or heated at home from fresh, the generous amount of turkey and other ingedients in the Turkey Dinner Pie makes this a huge hit. As a bonus, the cut portions are extremely easy to remove from the pan, without the filling 'gooping' out everywhere.
The only downside for my tastebuds is a slight hint of an HP Sauce-like flavour that I could do without.
Thanks for the review Julie :)
Amanda Woods said:
My favorite pie!
It’s so good, I’ve ordered it many times before. Hands down, their best pie!
Thanks for the review Amanda :)
The Best double butter crust!!!
Thanks Fab :)
Kelly Fairful said:
Turkey Dinner Pie
The pie was awesome. There was lots of turkey in the filling. The flavour was just like a turkey dinner. The filling was moist and the crust was tender.
So great! Thanks for the review Kelly :)
Jennifer March said:
Turkey dinner pie
Pie was delicious, pastry, turkey, cranberry - just perfect
No, YOU'RE perfect. Thanks Jennifer :)
Louise Ries said:
Turkey Dinner Pie
AMAZING!!! We loved it. This year we had ham for Cjhristmas Dinner, and I knew I needed a turkey fix, so got this pie. It was absolutely amazing! I will be ordering it whenever it is available. Even people who do not like turkey liked it.
Fantastic! So glad we could fill the hole, Louise ;P
Turkey Dinner Delight
The pie is delicious. It was the perfect combo of your typical turkey dinner all in one pie. Would definitely get again next Christmas!
That is awesome! Thanks for the review VB :)
Gabriel Applegath said:
Great pie full of turkey!
The Turkey pie was perfectly filled with the correct ratios, with abundant juicy Turkey spilling out everywhere. They were very generous with it, and we ate way too much. Couldn’t put it down.
Excellent! So glad it hit the mark, Gabriel :)
Lesley Opheim said:
TURKEY PIE MY OH MY
Excellent turkey dinner in a pie! It was perfect size (9 inch) for my family of four! Amazing and delicious!! Yummy everyone said at the table!!
Perfect! Unanimous decision :) Thanks so much Lesley.
Yummy turkey dinner all wrapped & ready to gobble gobble! very tasty & full of holiday seasonings & flavour. without all the hardwork of cooking. only thing missing is the pan gravy. moist enough you won’t miss it.
How great are those time savings, right? Thanks so much for the review Michele :)
Adam Yates said:
We got the thanksgiving pie to share with visiting family and it was perfect--an entire meal in a single pie and no mess to clean up afterwards. We will definitely be back for this again.
So great! Glad everyone liked it :) Thanks Adam
Lynn Joseph said:
Love this pie
Second year with a Christmas dinner pie then add brussel sprouts and gravy. Fantastic. 5” is perfect for two
Excellent! Keep the tradition alive ;) Thanks so much, Lynn.
Monica Girn said:
It was ok
It was moist. I could not taste the mashed potatoes or stuffing. I felt like it was mostly just turkey with a hint of cranberry. The crust was great.
Thanks for the review, Monica. Appreciate the feedback :)
M Carol W said:
Turkey dinner pie generously stuffed and delicious!
I’ve only ordered the turkey dinner hand pies and that was a couple of years ago. I always thought a full pie might have too much crust, but I was so wrong! The ratio of filling to crust is actually much higher. It’s packed full of real turkey dinner components and was absolutely delicious! I will be buying more full sized pies from now on! 😋
Go big or go home, right? Thanks for the review M Carol :)
Turkey Dinner Pie
Thanks HJ :)
Jolene Larson said:
The Turkey dinner pie is absolutely amazing. Couldn’t have asked for anything better. It was like Christmas in every bite. Highly recommended!
Thanks so much for saying so, Jolene! Cheers :)
Alex Tang said:
Turkey Pie Review
Taste great, portion is generous, price is fair. There is nothing to complain about my order. Will definitely order again.
Thanks so much Alex. We'll be ready when you are :)
Sharen Wesnoski said:
A "perfect" dinner!
I have ordered the turkey dinner pie on at least 6 occasions and not once have I been disappointed. It is FANTASTIC!!! I serve the pie with gravy, a vegetable, a salad and fresh buns - a dinner that I, and my guests, consider to be PERFECT!
Definitely sounds like a full meal Sharen! Thanks for the review :)
Kathleen Delorme said:
Review Hand Pies Turkey Dinner Pies
I enjoy the convenience of the hand pies for the turkey dinner pies. I was not quite prepared for the cranberry chutney style, but personally I enjoy it although my child was not a fan of this. I enjoy the flaky crust of the hand pies too and they are great for quick lunch or light dinner. I hope you will be able to make chicken potpie in handpie version too! The flavour is nice. Thanks!
Thanks for the review, Kathleen. We most definitely have Chicken Pot Pie hand pies! Guess where your next lunch is coming from? ;)
Max Cowan said:
Turkey Pie and Butterscotch for desert
The Turkey Pie was pretty good, if a bit bland. Full of Turkey though - they don't skimp - and the cranberry was nice.
The Butterscotch Pie was a hit though, maybe one of the best cream pies we've tried from your store.
Awesome! Thanks for the feedback Max :)
Kristiane Ross said:
Turkey Dinner Pie
Thanks Kristiane :)
Delightful Turkey Dinner Pie
This Turkey Dinner Pie was very good. I highly recommend and would definitely buy again. I quite enjoyed it for Thanksgiving and it was a nice alternative to doing a full turkey dinner if you're having a small gathering. Other reviews said it could have used more cranberry so I had some prepared extra on the side, which was enjoyed with the pie. I understand why it can't be too saucy or else it won't be able to hold in the pie crust itself. Pie crust was super delicious.
Smart planning, Tiff :) Glad you enjoyed it.
Marina Marzin said:
Making new traditions
The turkey pie was amazing. We will be having it every thanksgiving from now on!!!
Excellent! I wholeheartedly support your new tradition ;P Thanks Marina
Turkey dinner made easy
I love the idea of Turkey dinner in a pie. You don’t have to make any fuss in creating a full meal, but you get a bit of everything! The pie was great, though I wished for more even distribution of the cranberry sauce as one part of the pie didn’t have as much (this is saying a lot as I don’t even like cranberry sauce, but I loved it in this pie!). Delicious flakey crust can’t be beat.
So glad you liked it, Colene! It's true, there is some DIY involved with balancing the ratio of components in each forkful. Appreciate the review :)
William Holder said:
We purchased the Pie Hole Turkey Dinner for my elderly parents as an easy way for them to enjoy a Thanksgiving treat. It was a huge success! Cheers.
Adorable! I am so glad they could have a traditional turkey dinner without all the cooking fuss! Thanks for the review, William :)
Veronica Morganhart said:
Thanksgiving dinner made easy
We celebrated this year with the Pie Hole Turkey Dinner Pie and I hope they keep it around because I could eat this all year! The seasoning and flavor were so rich and delicious which is quite a feat with so many ingredients together with excellent balance. The cranberry was not too sweet, the turkey meat was tender, and the crust was, of course, outstanding. A whole thanksgiving meal in one 5" pie ready to eat in mere minutes - who could ask for more? Thanks so much, Pie Hole!
Yay! You are so welcome, Veronica! I love hearing when it hits the mark :)
Amanda C said:
I really enjoyed the flavours of the turkey dinner pie! I only wish there was a bit more cranberry sauce :) The 5" pie provided me with two generous servings.
Glad you liked it, Amanda! It's true, some ratio-tinkering may be necessary to suit personal tastes. Appreciate the review :)
Joyce Gee said:
Perfect proportion for singles
Delicious turkey pie and the 5 in is perfect for a single person. Dessert topped off with apple pie. The apple pie is made with real apples and not that canned overly sweet apples that most lower quality pies are made with.
Thanks for the review, Joyce :)
Delicious Turkey Dinner in a pie
Filling, and chock full of ingredients, this turkey dinner pie served 5 of us with leftovers! Really tasty and great texture shredded turkey. All ready to go, we just had to heat it up in the oven. Will be getting this again.
Awesome! Quick, easy, tasty, and filling. Checks all the boxes! Thanks Gina :)
Rebecca Grey said:
So nice I've ordered it twice
Last Thanksgiving I ordered this pie on a bit of a whim - my expectations were low. But it was so good that I ordered it again this year - it's a unique way to have a traditional turkey dinner with zero of the fuss!
Whimmer whimmer turkey dinner! Thanks so much Rebecca :P
Jess W. said:
Bourbon Pecan Pie!!!
Soooo good! My family devoured this. Absolutely recommend it.
Thanks so much Jessica :)