K. M. said:
Shepherds pie
creamy mash potatoes and loads of filling
Thanks K.M. :)
Carol said:
Comfort food at it's finest
The filling was rich and flavorful with just the perfect amount of mashed potatoes on top.
Excellent! Thanks for the review Carol :)
Jane MacFadgen said:
Shepherd’s pie
Your shepherd’s pie got a rave review from my 98 year old mother-in-law. High praise indeed!
Yay! Thanks to you and your mother in law, Jane :)
Leanna P said:
Delicious!
Shepherd’s pie and Fat Elvis pie were both decadent. Staff are friendly and welcoming. Pick up went smoothly even with a long line for Pi day!
So glad to hear pickup was smooth! Thanks for the review Leanna :)
Mariana Matranga said:
Just like my Grandma’s
I tried the handpies…. sooo good, I was hesitant because I used to love my grandma’s shepherds pie. This one was a tiny bit spicy, coming from someone with low tolerance to spice (take this comment carefully). My daughter LOVED it too Only 2 were left, and I brought them to my trip and ate them at room temperature. Delicious hot or cold. I will buy more.
That's so great to hear! If we can share the stage with a grandma's pie, we are happy to do so ;) Thanks Mariana
roderic macdougall said:
good eats
always consistent always tasty best around
Thanks so much Roderic :)
jerry keenan said:
Shepherds Pie
This pie with meat and mashed potatoes is so delicious ? I have purchased it several times, always scrumptious.
Thanks Jerry, glad you like it :)
Julie Craig said:
Amazing Shepherds pie
All the staples of a classic shepherds pie along with some warm spices to keep it from being bland. Loved it.
Thanks Julie! Glad you liked it :)
Jordan Tseng said:
Amazing pies
We loved the crust and fillings! Very good pie :D
Thanks so much Jordan :)
Jane DePaoli said:
Great Pies
We loved the Triple Chocolate Pies, it was quite yummy.
Thanks Jane :)
Naomi Seki said:
Pie party!
Thanks Naomi :)
Tanya! said:
YUMMY!!!
Soooo tasty! Wish the personal pie was a muuuuch bigger size as I didn’t want it to end lol creamy mash potatoes and nicely seasoned meat and veggies!
If it helps, you can call the 9' pie the 'Personal Size Pro' and just go to town ;) Thanks for the review, Tanya.
EB said:
Shepherd's Pie
*string of unintelligible lip-smacking and drooling sounds*
Outstanding! Ridiculously delicious!
haha thanks, Elijah. Don't talk with your mouth full ;)
Maris Sulcs said:
Shepherds Pie
Re-heat instructions - pie started to burn after 20 minutes. Had to cover it with foil. Crust a bit sticky at bottom, but very appropriate for the pie. Plenty of excellent seasoning and vegetables - complete meal. Very good - would have it again.
Nice work with the re-heating adjustments :) Thanks for the review, Maris.
Cyndi Davey said:
Sheppard/Vietnamese
I loved loved loved your crust! The shep p ards pie was good just a little too salty for me, but son loved it. Your Vietnamese pie 🥧was yum. Thank goodness I bought a little one because if I had bought the 9" I would have eaten it all.
Know thyself, right? haha Thanks for the review, Cyndi :)
D Franklin said:
Shepherds Pie
Had this for the first time this week and it won’t be the last. Really well balanced and the crust was to die for.
Awesome! Thanks D Franklin :)
Jen S said:
Another hit!
The filling was delicious, moist and flavourful. The crust, as always, flaky and rich! Mashed potatoes were moist and fluffy, perfection:)
Wow! Thanks Jen. Appreciate the shepherding ;)
Maricar Angeles said:
Shepherds Pie - delicious!!
Decided to try the Shepherds Pie after loving the Bacon Cheeseburger Pie. This did not disappoint! It was flavorful, packed with filling and not to forget the perfect pie crust. Highly recommend it.
Fantastic! On to the next challenge, eh? Thanks Maricar :)
mazdasam said:
Shepherds hand-pies
Done well. Loved the ground lamb!
Thanks mazdasam :)
Masumi Komori said:
Shepherds Pie Hand Pies
The baked 9" Shepherd pies were all sold out - so we had to go with the hand pies and OMG, Jenell - they were absolutely amazing! They were tasty, the texture of the crust was awesome and the ease of baking up the frozen hand pies was sooo nice. Thanks, for offering these different size and baking options along with all your delicious choices in both sweet and savoury pies!
You are so very welcome, Masumi! I'm glad you were able to at least score some hand pies (nothing wrong with more of that Double Butter Crust, am I right?). Appreciate the review :)
Shellina Tarmohamed said:
Shepard’s pie!
We ordered a Shepard’s pie and it was so delicious that we had to order another one a week later! Thank you for all the goodness
Managing the flock...right into your bellies haha. Thanks for the review, Shellina :) You are most welcome!
Toni Forbes said:
Shepard’s Pie
First time buying from Pie Hole. Really enjoyed the Shepard's Pie! Looking forward to trying other savoury offerings.
...and thus, a life-long bond was formed. Welcome to the fold, friend :) Look forward to hearing about your next experience!
peggy g said:
Loved the shepherds pie
It was so delicious and the 9inch fed the two of us for several meals. Will definitely order again!
Meals
Awesome! Glad you guys got several belly fills out of it, Peggy :) ...Meals ;P
M. Mani said:
Perfect for weeknight dinner.
I purchased the Shepard’s Pie hand pies frozen making them a convenient weeknight dinner option or perfect after a day out skiing. Delicious and easy!
Nice! Burn those calories ;) Thanks for the review, M. Mani.
David Moorey said:
Shepherd Pie Review
Fabulous. I so enjoyed the Shepard Pie, I ordered the 5" size a perfect size a meal, I will order more! The staff, great service!
Awesome! Thanks David :)
E Nandi said:
Shepherd’s Pie
I tried the 5” Shepherd’s pie this time and it was really good. I would order it again, only I’d get the bigger size next time..
Great! Thanks Ellora :)
Marly Sas said:
Amazing service.!
I wasn’t able to make my original pick up date to pick up the pie 🥧 I had called and they held it for me ! These pies are amazingly delicious 😋 love the shepherds pie and turkey dinner pie!
Thanks, Marly! Glad we could make it work :)
Jenny Lam said:
Tasty Handpies
I am truly loving these handpies. I wasn't sure how the mashed potatoes would fare within the crust but it was excellent. Will definitely get again. Also, I really love your handpies - perfect size, no waste, shorter baking time, whats not to love? I will definitely buy your pies in handpie form from now on!
Excellent! Delicious pie comes in all shapes and sizes ;) Thanks, Jenny.
Julie Adair said:
BEST SHEPHERDS PIE EVER!!!
So much meaty lamby goodness in each bite! Perfect flaky crust and excellent meat-to-potato ratio! Thanks! 😋
Awesome! Glad the balance worked well for you, Julie. Thanks a bunch :)
Anonymous. said:
One of the ultimate comfort pies!
Wonderful pie! Seasoning, vegetables ,topping and crust all very well balanced!
Yes! Guide that flock of flavour straight into your mouth, haha. Thanks Randi :)
CG said:
Wow - what a pie!
While I do not eat meat, I recently ordered a small Shepherd's pie for my husband. The smell of the pie baking and the aroma after it came out of the oven were too much for even me - I had to try a spoonful immediately - so delicious, even for someone who doesn't eat meat!
Glad you were able to appreciate it even without full indulgence, CG ;) Thanks for the review
Amy T said:
Sooo yummy
the pie was so good. The double butter crust is always a winner.
Thanks Amy :)
David Antonio said:
Got to Hand it to the Hand Pies
Hand Pies halved, and with a side dish from home, make an excellent lunch for less than most lunch places.
-David A. A Pie Hole Junkie since Feb 2019
Thanks for saying so David. Your addiction is appreciated ;)
Alice C said:
Awesome pies
Pre-ordered the blueberry goat cheese pie. Easy pick up and super yummy! Not too sweet, just right.
Also had the shepherds pie very delicious! Will definitely order again.
Dinner and dessert. Got the entire night covered ;) Thanks Alice.
Ray Shin said:
Pre-order pickup was smooth and pies were delicious as always
Delicious hand pies. Picked up a frozen batch of the Shepherds Pie. Had to pop one in the oven right when I got home. And the Raspberry Cream Pie was perfect as always. Always quality pies fro Piehole!
Thanks for the review, Ray! Appreciate it :)
Victoria Johnson said:
Yummy!
Love that the mashed potatoes has a little crunch, and the lamb and beef filling tastes just right! The perfect dinner for a busy day: just heat up and eat!
Glad you liked it Victoria. Thanks for the review :)
Riaz Kassam said:
Awesome Pies
We are addicted! trying different pies all,of the time and have yet to be disappointed. In fact they are truely amazing.
Thanks so much for comments, Riaz! I hope they all become your favourite ;)
Happy said:
Delicious!
Delicious! Pick up was also super easy. Thank you!
The Pie Hole trifecta: great service, delicious pie...and you! Thanks Happy :)
Chuck L said:
Almost like Mom's!
I grew up having my Mom's homemade Sheperd's Pie (or Pate Chinoix as we called it in Quebec).
This one comes pretty close !! By the way HP sauce makes a great condiment with this Pie !
Thanks for the review, Charles. The Shepherds Pie definitely strums the down-home, comfort food strings.
Ling said:
Awesome
Super yummy all gone. Will be back to buy again soon. Thank you pie hole 😍😍
Thanks Ling xiao Chang! You keep eating em and we'll keep making em ;) See you next time!
Jane Walton said:
Quick and easy meal
I love all the pies that I've tried here. Best ever crust from a bakery!
Thanks, Jane!
Cathie Hahnel said:
Delicious shepherd's pie