Jason Brawn said:
A celebrated combination taken up a notch.
I’ve yet to muster the self control required to order a 9” version of this pie. I carefully choose those times I’ll be dining with someone I know shares my passion for peanut butter and chocolate, then share responsibly. I’ve tried to order a different sweet pie each time in order to get through the entire catalogue of amazing Pie Hole treats, but I can’t help myself…this is now a regular treat. But only when I have company. Because however many are present when the lid comes off, it’ll all be gone soon thereafter. I’ve said it before, but this may now be my favourite Pie Hole sweet pie…
haha Guilty pie pleasures are so much easier to justify when it's a GROUP of pie lovers ;) I accept your reservation of the right to change favourite flavours at any point, Jason. Appreciate the review :)
Jenna Kissel said:
Thank you Jenna :)
Miranda Kowalski said:
The Bomb.com
Well hot damn I went nuts for this pie. So creamy and the perfect ratio of chocolate and peanut butter goodness. The Pie Hole really knows how to perfect the perfect treat for a peanut butter cup lover.
If the peanut butter cup crowd feels this way, we have done our job :) Thanks so much Miranda.
Riaz Kassam said:
Great pies
Ron said:
Peanut Butter Heaven
Rich and creamy, and sooooooo delicious! Just the right balance of flavours. Our new favourite!!!
Long live the chocopeabutt king! Thanks Ron :)
Catherine said:
Reese's Peanut Butter Pie
If you are looking for a rich, decadent, chocolatey pie, this is for you. This is hands down one of my new favourite pies from The Pie Hole. I served it to my friends this weekend and they loved it. They asked me for the address of the closest pie hole to where they live. They have a lifetime customer in me!
That's so awesome to hear Catherine! Very much appreciate your support and spreading the word :)
A said:
Delish!
Tasted like a Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup - in pie form. So good, will have to order a larger size next time!
haha it doesn't last long once you realize how good it tastes, huh? Thanks so much for the review Aysha :)
Courtney Babcock said:
Peanut Butter Heaven!
Do you like chocolate, do you like peanut butter? look no further, this pie will satisfy all your cravings and leave you wanting more!
Yes! PB/chocolate fans rejoice! YOUR pie is here! Thanks Courtney :)
Maria Humphreys said:
Which came first?
The Reese’s peanut butter cups or Reese’s peanut butter pie ADDICTION? Either way, the pie is so good....especially the peanut butter cookie crust!
Just tastes like they belong together, doesn't it? Thanks for the review Maria.
Stephen Tam said:
Awesome Pie!
Great filling and crust! not too sweet!
Perfect! Thanks so much Stephan :)
Kristen Pidgeon said:
Don't share
It was awful....I was saving the last piece to enjoy as a heavenly snack before bed with some Netflix, but I walked into the kitchen to find my dessert-hating partner devouring the last piece, instead. It's reasonable grounds for divorce, I would say.
So it's delicious, buy it, but don't share.
haha noooo! Pie should bring people together, not legally separate them!! ...but I get it ;) Thanks for the review Kristen.
K-Rob said:
Peanut Butter Heaven!!!!
The Peanut Butter Cup pie is simply perfection! The perfect treat for chocolate and peanut butter lovers! Will definitely be buying this one again and highly recommend it! The Pie Hole hit this one outta the park.
Awesome! Thanks K-Rob! So glad you liked it :)
Melanie said:
Best Peanut Butter Cup pie...EVER
The Pie Hole's pies are the best we've ever had! Thanks for a bit of joy in these crazy times :)
Of course! We are all too happy to spread some delicious comfort whenever we can :) Thanks Melanie.
Robert MacLeod said:
Peanut Butter Pie
Thanks Robert
Carmen S. said:
Unbelievably good!
I don’t know what mad genius was at play here but The Pie Hole has created the ultimate chocolate peanut butter dessert. It really is like a giant peanut butter cup only better because it’s also encased in a delicious crust. Highly recommend!
For sure. Any fan of the choco/pbutt combo should do themselves a favour and try this one ;)
Guilherme Dourado said:
Creamy, crumbly, beautiful
I'm a peanut butter fan and often find peanut butter pies to lack depth of flavor, but this is a perfect mix of the creamy filling, rich chocolate ganache and crumbly crust.
My only regret was getting a 5" instead of the 9".
This is Piefection (wink wink)!
Excellent! Thanks for the review Guilherme. Don't live with regrets...that 9' is waiting for you ;)
Betania Bolognese said:
Best crumble
The caramel apple crumble was probably the best pie I have ever had. The pie crust was so flaky and buttery, the filling was delicious. Can’t wait to go back!!
That's great Betania! You know where to find us :)
RP said:
Very Delicious
This pie is very good. The graham crust compliments the chocolate peanut butter combo nicely, as well as the flavoured cream. The combination of flavours all work really well together, I’m glad I finally tried this pie, would definitely purchase again!
Awesome to hear! Thanks Rochelle. Chocolate and peanut butter is a real symphony for some :)
Peter Spangler said:
Yooooooooooooooooooooooooo
Hi Peter - thanks for your 'dope' review!
Elaine McMillan said:
Delicious!
Delicious pie!! So easy to order and staff are so friendly. Will definitely order again!