My mother still holds the title for the best pie but Piehole now holds the title for the best store bought pie I have ever bought.

My family and I loved the Key Lime Pie! It had the perfect amount of sweetness and tartness, and the graham crust was lovely. We’ll definitely order it again, and are looking forward to trying all the other pies.

Ordered a few pies for a dinner event. All were great and the variety for dessert is wonderful. Everyone’s favourite was the lemon meringue and the chocolate espresso. Key lime in second place and would have been top pie but just needs a bit stronger lime presence. Lastly, the kits location was wonderful. Great staff!

This is the second time that I’ve purchased this pie for family events and it’s a huge hit!

this tastes as good as home
made. will definitely be purchasing again!

No comments for improvement other than to have a Vancouver location to save having to drive out to New Westminster for picking up orders.

Best Key Lime pie we have had.
Smooth and delicious. Will recommend to others.

Key Lime, Apple Caramel Crumble and to Die For Banana Cream Pies…all absolutely delicious; however, the crusts were a bit too thick for the small pie sizes.

Ordered the pie once via a school fundraiser and it was amazing. It sells out so quickly but it's amazing if you sink your teeth into it! They have other sweets the kids like (smore cookie is one). Definitely recommend this bakery.

Your key limes are wonderful!!

Unique pies! I loved it

pies feed a lot of people and is a definite crowd pleaser

Really enjoyed it.

Best Key Lime Pie I've had in Vancouver. Amazing! Great service as well.

Pie hole was very honest and communicative about their back order on their gluten free ingredients needed to make a GF key lime pie for me. It was for my friend’s 40th birthday and all the stars were aligned and the back order came the week I needed the pie! It is the perfect and best key lime pie because it has the perfect balance of sour and sweet! I wouldn’t order a key lime pie anywhere else and the bonus was it had to be gluten free just for the birthday girl! Thank you Pie Hole!!

The pie was the right combination of tart and sweet with an excellent graham wafer crust. Still prefer the texture of Cactus Club Key lime however. Looking for one that will knock that from top spot.

This little pie was delicious. A bit too sweet for my tastes but nice to accompany with coffee or tea. Very nice taste and texture as well.

This is the third time I’ve ordered from the Pie Hole, and they have yet to disappoint! The Key Lime is my family’s favourite.

Ordered the key lime pie for a recent dinner party and it was a hit! The explosion of taste along with the tasty crust made it a crowd pleaser. Highly recommended.

So good, creamy, citrusy, mmm. Now added to my self care rotation at the Piehole <3

I have yet to meet a Pie Hole pie I didn’t like. My daughter requested the key lime pie for her birthday “cake”, and it did not disappoint.

I give them my highest rating: “I want more!!!” I bought for my birthday after seeing yours as top rated for this type of pie. Now i don’t want to share the pie with anyone.

My cats also liked the pie. Their rating is also “I want more”.

Pie was delicious, questions asked prior to ordering were answered quickly (online), will purchase there again.

Very tasty and almost as I remember from when I was living in Miami. Of course that was 50 years ago.

Loved the Key Lime Pie - as delicious as what we had recently in Key West!!
Thank you!

I brought this key lime pie to a family dinner, and suffice to say, it was a HUGE HIT! Even my father-in-law, who isn’t a fan of desserts, said it was really good. The perfect amount of sweet and sour.

I have a friend who is a self-professed connoisseur of key lime pie and this is his very favourite. we get it for his birthday every year because, as he says, "who needs cake when this pie is so good!"

Pie was excellent

My fiance is obsessed with Key Lime Pies but they can be hard to find sometimes. The Pie Hole has amazing key lime pies that are so juicy and so creamy!

This is by far and away the best Key Lime Pie.
That's it!

By the way, the hill I will die on will be littered with empty pie dishes. I apologise in advance for littering this beautiful wilderness and will ensure an instruction to clean the dishes up will be included in my will.

The pie was everything I had expected it to be. As well your staff were super friendly !

A pie I would order again- really good and the right amount of tartness!

Ordered the lemon meringue and key lime pies and they did not disappoint. The depth of flavour and sweet and sour balance was perfect, and the pies were so smooth!

This key lime pie is just right. The filling is deliciously tart, the cream sweet, and the gingerbread crust special. This is one of my go-to pies when guests are coming over. Or even if not. :-)

very tasty ate it all in one night was so good and then decided to make one of my own

Key Lime pie was absolutely excellent. Ordering on line was easy and pick up was seamless. It’s a good thing I don’t live closer because I guarantee I’d put on about 5 kilos a week if I did. Cheers. And what’s this I hear about a mini egg Easter pie?

Wonderful product coupled with great service.

Very good. I always worry pies might be too sweet since I go for savory more but this 👌 💯 perfect amount of sweetness.

This was the best key lime pie I’ve ever had. The 5 inch was perfect for 4 of us. The perfect dessert.

We ordered 2 items and they were delish. I appreciated being able to call and have a friend who lived nearby pick it up for me. Thanks so much.

Straight from my three year old’s mouth: “I really enjoyed that pie. Yep, I did.”
Yep, we did.

My work orders from the Pie Hole for every birthday celebration and its now my new favorite thing. All the pies we've tried have all been absolutely delicious!

I’m a fair baker and found key lime pie recipes pretty straight forward so I was a bit skeptical when my husband suggested we order one from the Pie Hole. But holy cow!!!! It was fantastic- I mean seriously good- I now want it as my birthday‘cake’ - go ahead and order - it’s worth it!

Great pie tart, and sweet.

Ordered a few pies to try out, and also one for a birthday. All of them were fantastic and surpassed our expectations.

Not tart, crust was a little too thick

A definite must have, run don’t walk to your nearest The Pie Hole ☺️

Key lime pie looked beautiful. Fresh - but I was hoping for a tart keylime pie. This was very sweet and very creamy. Loved your peach Bellini pie though!!!

Very tasty, fresh. I have eaten Key Lime in Florida. I am used to more tartness. It was still a very good little pie.

I made a key lime pie for my son’s birthday last year and squeezing all those tiny limes took FOREVER! Delicious, but way too much work. The pie hole key lime pie was just as good and I got four hours of my life back.

The Key Lime Pie at The Pie Hole is delicious! It has the right balance of tart and sweet.

Definitely a family favourite! Perfectly balanced between sweet and tart. It has just the right amount of whipped cream, and the crust is delicious! Would highly recommend!

The real deal. I flavor is right between a burst & an explosion of flavor with a perfect balance of crust to filling. The best Key Lime Pie I have ever had. Magic.

The system worked perfectly. I went online, ordered, paid through a credit card, and it sent me a confirmation. All worked without a glitch.

Dan

Delicious as always. Perfect balance between tart and sweet. The crust forks easily. I’m addicted.

The key lime pie was delicious, not too sweet and a great balance of graham crust to key lime filling. It was a mouthful of sunshine on a rainy day, loved it!

Purchased this for my husband's birthday! It was a WIN! He loved it and it was So fresh and very tasty! Will be purchasing it again :)

This is my dad’s favourite kind of pie, so I definitely did my homework for his 65th bday. It led me to The Pie Hole, which did not disappoint! I won’t tell you how many pieces he consumed, suffice to say it made his day. I even got a text the next day saying the key lime pie was even better day two. Will absolutely be trying other flavours.

I have been eating a small slice each day and loving every forkful. My only suggestion to make it 5+ is to consider making it more tangy.

I needed to order a pie for my boyfriend’s birthday and I am stuck 2000 miles away due to COVID. They did an amazing job helping me get my order completed and even called when a banana cream pie was available for order. Thank you for making his day so special!

Amazing key lime pie with a delicious crust. It had a great amount of whipped cream on it! Pick up was quick and efficient, which I appreciated as well.

Love the key lime pie, can’t wait to try the rest of them pies

Was so easy to order this pie online. Ordered in place of birthday cake and the pie did not disappoint. The Birthday boy loved it! Definitely see more pie in our future!

Not the "best" key lime Pie I've ever had (I'm a bit of a key lime Aficionado) but it's up there. What it's lacking in shear Tanginess it makes up for in smoothness and creaminess! I couldn't eat the whole 9" pie in one sitting (or even 2 or 3) so I put some in my freezer for future enjoyment...

We loved this pie, and we will get it again.
And again.

Key Lime Pie is one of my favourite pies and The Pie Hole offers it as one of their staple pies, it is sooo tasty, not too tart and not too sweet it's got the right balance. The crust is so good, it is thick enough so that it doesn't get too soggy from the filling. It'll be one of my go-to pies from this place!

This is absolutely the best key lime pie we have ever eaten. It was difficult not eating the entire pie the first night! The crust was bolstering with flavor and so flaky and tender! The pie wasn’t overly sweet and what I didn’t expect was the whipped cream to taste as good as it did. Would definitely purchase again!

This was the first time I tried a Key Lime Pie and I must admit, it was incredibly delicious! Fabulous balance of sweet and tart - now I'm hooked!

My comment title says it all.

Fantastic pie, a definite top contender!!! I would order again for sure & recommend to anyone!!

We had it for a family celebration and everyone who had some enjoyed it. It is not too sour or too sweet. It is a refreshing summer pie!

This is my sister's favorite pie. The filling is pretty tart. I like the lime zest on top!

The Key Lime pie was delicious; however, it could have more lime tartness and less on the sweet side.

All of us like the pie!