Katelyn Milne said:
Omg
I went in today to grab a frozen apple crumble for Christmas which I also grabbed but I saw egg nog rum and had to try. I was very disappointed that I only grabbed a small one because OMG. It tasted just like it's name. My husband was also raving, I'm going to have to go back and get a big one now. I wish this was a all year flavor.
Chelsea Comeau said:
Festive and tasty
Lots of egg nog fans in our house, and we were not disappointed by this pie! Great texture and strong egg nog flavour...we would definitely order this one again!
Yay! (the eggnog fan stamp of approval is pretty important for this one haha). Much appreciated Chelsea :)
Jen S said:
Holiday treat
We enjoyed the eggnog pie, nice and creamy, graham crust was perfect. No ba humbugs from anyone! A hit!
Thanks so much Jen!
Cherrel Reid said:
Eggnog and Rum pie
This pie was delicious! just the right balance of rum and egg nog. It is a great dessert after Christmas dinner!
Yay noggy xmas pie :P Thanks for the review Cherrel
Debbie Braich said:
Ordered 2 pies online
Ordered 2 pies at the Langley location. Pick up was quick and easy. Staff were friendly
Excellent! Glad to hear it Debbie :)
L Cheng said:
Delicious!
5” pie had a perfect filling to crust ratio! Great eggnog flavour!
Thanks Lammie! Glad you liked it :)
C.I. said:
The best Christmas pie ever
Picked up the eggnog and rum pie for Christmas dinner and this is definitely my favourite Christmas pie now - maybe my favourite pie ever! Creamy, smooth, light, spicy and sweet. So so good.
Awesome! Nothing like matching tasty pies with appreciative stomachs ;) Thanks C.I.
KaisNW said:
Christmas in my mouth!
Pre-ordered the Eggnog & Rum Pie and Apple Cranberry Pie for pick up from the Burnaby location. The order was ready and pick up was smooth. Both pies were delicious! The flavours were rich and tasted exactly as expected. Would recommend both for your Christmas get-togethers.
All good stuff, for sure. Thanks so much for the review KaisNW :)
Max Cowan said:
Taste is spot on.
It's like Eggnog but in pie form!
Thanks Max :)
Michelle Shen said:
Sweet and Festive
It's creamy with a strong eggnog flavour. The crust is moist and pairs nicely with the filling. Perfect festive treat for eggnog lovers.
Absolutely! Thanks for the review Michelle :)
Mark Topacio said:
Taste of Christmas
I’m always looking forward Xmas to have this flavour
So true. For some, eggnog is THE Christmas flavour. Thanks Mark :)
Chris WM said:
Buy Two
Bought a 9 lunch rum and eggnog for Christmas dessert. Also bought a 5 inch pecan to help ensure that the big pie made it home. The pecan did not. Yes they are that good.
lol I wonder if the small Butter Pecan pie knew it was a car-ride sacrifice when you bought it. Glad to hear they were both enjoyed. Thanks for the review, Chris :)
Daniela MacLean said:
Eggnog & Rum Pie
Absolutely delicious. Gave half of pie away to a relative and later when I had a taste of my half realized that I should have ordered two in the first place!
haha darn that inherent generosity of yours! At least now you know for next year ;) Thanks Mara.
Iris Chia said:
Love each bite!
The Pie Hole does it again!! This eggnog and rum pie is sooo goood! I will definitely be buying this one again :)
Thanks so much, Iris :) Make sure you get it while it's still here!
Charmaigne PFLUGRATH said:
A True Festive Favourite
So good. A seasonal sensation just like the beverage. My new festive favourite! (Sorry, Gingerbread Cream Pie.)
Awesome! So glad to hear it, Charmaigne! Don't worry about offending Gingerbread. He and Eggnog are old buddies ;)
Karin Hung said:
Eggnog and Rum
Absolutely delicious! A holiday delight for those who love eggnog!
Too true! Get your eggnog fix in pie form! Thanks Karin :)
Richard Williams said:
Eggnog Rum Pie
My family purchased your Eggnog pie for my son’s birthday (his choice). We were not sure to expect as this was a non-traditional pie, but we liked the flaky crust although there was a some liquid or moisture in the pie tin. The flavour of filing was good and not over powered by nutmeg.
Thanks Richard! Happy bday to your son (who has great taste). Appreciate the review.
Florence said:
A Not To Be Missed Christmas Pie
Not feeling Christmassy? Then it’s time to dig into a slice of The Pie Hole’s Eggnog & Rum pie. Just the right amount of eggnog flavour and a decent amount of whip cream all in a lovely flaky crust. Santa would approve and may even give up cookies for this pie.
Whoa! A Santa-cookie-replacing pie?! Now that's holiday praise!
Ms. Hansen said:
Eggnog & Rum anyone?
A wonderful pie to transport you to a festive Christmas celebration! Taste is spot on!
Thank you, Ms. Hansen! (hooo, I am for reeeeal...you left me no choice there). Appreciate the review :)
Courtney Babcock said:
Best Christmas Pie EVER!
I wait all year for this eggnog pie and oh boy did I get excited when I saw the email letting me know it was finally the day I'd get to order it again! Hands down the best pie i've ever had in my life. Its such a treat!
I think you might be the biggest fan the Eggnog & Rum Pie has ever had in IT'S life! haha Thanks so much for the review, Courtney :) I hope you get to enjoy it a few more times before it disappears!
DH said:
The Best!!
One of my fav pies - rich and creamy, eggnog&rum flavour - in a perfect pastry shell. A must-have over the holidays!
Awesome, DH! We agree! This is a holiday pie if there ever was one :)
Ray Y. said:
eggnog & rum pie
Fiona Wray said:
Awesome eggnog flavour
These were very popular at our Christmas party. It is hard to find an ‘eggnog’ item that really tastes like eggnog. These were perfect!
Awesome! So glad we could hit the right eggnote for you, Fiona :)
Endre said:
Like a Christmas party in my mouth!
I’m going on record here and declare this an instant holiday classic. I’ve had a myriad of pastries in many forms (scones, muffins, etc.) that try to capture the egg nog essence and, as an egg nog fanatic, have been left disappointed. Usually the flavour isn’t strong enough or is too in-your-face. This pie though is the real deal. Lovely texture in the filling and flavouring is spot on. If you like egg nog, you owe it to yourself to indulge in one of these puppies.
Happy holidays indeed!
A thousand times YES, Endre!! What an excellent review! If pies could beam with pride, the Eggnog & Rum would be lighting up the room (the bakers are pretty proud too ;) Happy Holidays to you and yours.