This pie cannot be customized
Oh no you didn’t...oh yes we did! Crispy, gooey, rich and chewy - this is all your guilty pleasures in one pie. Ultra-buttery pecan-chocolate-chip-and-oat cookie with house-made caramel and finished with a rocky road topping. Pick up a pint of ice cream to really go all-in and you won’t care that you are spending Valentine’s Day alone (or with fellow feeling-eaters).
Dark Chocolate Chips, Heavy Cream, Flour, Butter, Milk, Oats, Cocoa Powder, Brown Sugar, Vanilla, Sugar, Pecans, Free Range Eggs, Espresso, Marshmallows, Baking Soda, Lemon Juice, Salt
Make sure to get the most enjoyable and best experience out of our pies by following the baking instructions and serving tips below. These instructions are specific to Eat Your Feelings. If you would like instructions for a different pie, please check that page.
The Eat Your Feelings should be refrigerated at all times. For best results, the pie should be consumed within 3 days of purchase. Before serving, please remove from fridge and leave at room temperature for 30 minutes. Ideally you do not want your cream pie to sit at room temperature for longer than 1 hour.
All pies ordered online are ready after 12 noon on your selected date (chosen during checkout).
Using online shopping you can order pies in 9-inch, 5-inch, 3-inch (9-pack), hand pie (5-pack), or mini hand pies (12-pack).
To order this product online, select a size followed by selecting options (like the ‘Top’ or ‘Frozen’, if applicable) and then click on “Add to Cart”. As you go through the checkout process, you will be able to specify a date for pick up. At least 36 hours notice is required from the time you order (the system will not let you select a date in advance of this time). Your order will be freshly made and ready for you on the date specified!
Or come visit us at one of our locations for a freshly baked slice, pop tart, or savoury hand pie to enjoy right there or packaged up to go. We also keep rotating stock on hand (first come, first served basis) of the 9-inch and 5-inch pies for those looking to take out.
Lastly, you can visit one of our Partner Retailers and pick up a pie there. Please call them in advance, as their stock is sure to be limited.
We take great pride in making each pie from scratch, by hand, and from locally sourced ingredients of the finest quality. Should you be unhappy with your pie, please return it to the shop you purchased it from and a credit will be applied upon the discretion of the Manager.