Colleen's Mistake

Colleen's Mistake
Colleen's Mistake
Colleen's Mistake

$30.00 for

1 review

Colleen's Mistake

1 review

This pie is a delicious accident that happened one day in the bakery and it is now here to stay! Our buttery crust is filled with a rich chocolate fudgey centre and topped with maple candied salted pecans and house made whipped cream and caramel sauce. Similar to a Turtle Pie, only way better.  This has quickly become The Pie Hole's favourite mistake.


Select a Size



3" Individual


About Our Pies

Our pies come in a few different sizes....

Online you can custom order any of the available pies in 9 inch, 5 inch, 3 inch 6 packs, 4 savoury handpies, or sweet little two bite fruit pies on sticks (pie pops). Online orders require 48hrs notice and your pie(s) are baked fresh for you and waiting!

Or come visit us at the bakery for a slice of pie, individual 3" pies and or savory handpies heated up to enjoy in the shop or packaged up for those on the run. We also keep rotating stock on some of the favorites in the 9" full pies and 5" pies for those looking to pick up something for dinner or dessert.

All our 9", 5" and multi packs prices include tax, so no surprises! Taxes are added to individual 3”, Hand Pies, Pie Tarts and slices.

Ordering Details

If this pie appears in list of pies Available This Week, it may be freshly made as of this morning and in stock. Please call 604-428-2743 to reserve and pick up this pie today!

Alternatively, you can order this pie online by selecting from the various sizes, as well as options (select pies only) such as frozen, fresh, lattice top, etc., and then click on “Add to Cart”. As you go through the checkout process, you will be able to specify a date for pick up that is at least 2 days from today or longer. Your order will be freshly made for you on the date specified and ready for pick up!

If you're still not sure about the whole “Internet" thing and you would prefer to place your order in person, please visit our store or visit one of our Partner Retailers.


  • Pecans
  • Chocolate
  • Butter
  • Eggs
  • Maple Syrup
    Maple Syrup

Butter, Flour, White Sugar, Chocolate, Cream, Nutella, Vanilla, Eggs, Pecans, Maple Syrup, Maldon Sea Salt, Icing Sugar, Cream Stabilizer, Brown Sugar