Pecan pie tasted fine but was misshapen. I was serving it to others so would have liked a better looking product.
Sorry the pie did not hold it's shape when baking, Rachael. Thanks for the feedback.
charles leduc said:
Nutty Pie !
Mostly Pecans + a bit of sugar and + a dose of Foodie Love !
Thanks Charles :)
Kathy Schlattman said:
Delicious Pie - thick with pecans! The Pie Hole Butter Pecan is now our new tradition! Effortless online order and eazey peazey pickup! Awesome Staff!
Thank you so much, Kathy! Really appreciate it :)
Nina Tan said:
Great flavour. Can't go wrong with pecan pie!
The candied pecans and pie filling were delicious. It was very rich, but it wasn't too too sweet. It tasted like a classic pecan pie. I served it to friends and it was a crowd-pleaser. The only complaint was that the pie crust was less flaky than I would have liked, almost like it was slightly overworked.
Thanks for the review and feedback, Nina. Glad you guys liked it :)
Diana Robertson said:
Butter Pecan Pie
This pie lived up to its name - buttery! The pecans were plentiful and added a delicious nutty crunch.
Thanks Diana :) Appreciate it.
Amanda Whitten said:
The best pecan pie I've ever had- wow !
Awesome!! Thanks so much Amanda :)
Cyrus Pun said:
Best Pecan Pie in Town
I always order their Pecan Pie especially for Thanksgiving. Always a crowd pleaser!
Awesome! Thanks so much Cyrus :)
Maria B said:
A must-have for pecan lovers!
Thanks Maria :)
Scot Atkinson said:
Like clockwork. And delicious
Online order and pick up was easy. And we all enjoyed the pies!
Excellent! Thanks Scot :)
Carol Smith said:
Pecan Pie Everytime!!
A favourite pie for birthday celebrations. This pie is the amazing and never disappoints.
Thanks for the review Carol. And 'happy birthday' to all relevant parties ;P
kelley phipps said:
Excellent, we will back again.
Thanks Kelley :)
Hit between a rock & a hard place… in Pecan Pie land
hmm… make that between chock-full of pecans & rich-goo..dness in to 'Pie-for' (double butter) crust instead —> each bite will outperform the next!
It simply leaves you wanting more… between their classic Butter Pecan Pie or their Chocolate Pecan Pie (adding balance to offset the sweet) next time around ;)
Fantastic! Thanks so much Joanna :)
Tina Rovatti said:
Simply, a perfect pecan pie!
How do I describe this … the inside was the perfect combination of buttery-pecan smoothness and the crust, oh man the crust! I have never tasted a crust like the ones made at The Pie Hole! This pie was perfectly delicious!
Yay! Thanks so much, Tina! Really appreciate the review :)
Where’s the crust?
I love love Pie Hole Pie… it’s really a must for special occasions. I love gifting them to friends and family, it’s always a delicious treat. My last two orders however were really lacking crust. The crust didn’t even go past the filling line on both my pumpkin and pecan pies. I had ordered them in advance and have to admit I was disappointed when I picked them up. Most of the time with pie, it’s not a big deal but this crust is so beyond delicious I wouldn’t want to miss a bite.
Thanks for the feedback, Lori! We do toot our own crust horn, so we definitely don't want to be shorting anyone! Will investigate... Much appreciated :)
Ian Poole said:
Pecan pie and mince tarts
Pecan pie was out of this world…mince tarts were delicious but embarrassingly chintzy.
Glad you liked the Pecan Pie, Ian :) Thanks for the feedback.
My girlfriend and I had this together and it was absolutely delicious. Had a bit of an alcohol aftertaste? Might be my imagination but it almost tasted like whiskey. Either way it was so good.
There may or may not be a splash of bourbon in that pie, Brendan ;P So glad you liked it!
Nutty sweet ‘n Yummy
butter pecan pie was very tasty. good crust. warmed it up & gobbled it down. 5” perfect to share. Also had the Chicken pot pie. totally delicious combination.
Chicken Pot Pie and Butter Pecan. CPP & BP. 'cippy bippy'? 'chickpeckbutt'? There's gotta be a fun mash-up name in there somewhere! Anyways, good picks and thanks for the review Michele :)
Martin Miyata said:
Often the picture of food looks way better than what you actually get! Not the case for the butter pecan pie. Look and taste is fanatabulous!
Angelique Leung said:
My mom said the pecan pie was ‘so so’, until we realized she didn’t want us to eat too much of it
haha That is some chess-move pie wisdom right there. Thanks for the review Angelique :)
David Charron said:
Butter pecan pie
Wow. All the pies at The Pie Hole are great but the butter pecan is at a whole different level of amazing.
Sounds like someone has a favourite ;) Thanks so much David
Hastey Safaie said:
I had the pleasure of trying the Butter Pecan Pie.. & WOW! My family & I absolutely loved the pie. The crust was phenomenal! Buttery & delicious! The filling was great too, tons of pecan pieces. I very happy I heard about this little GEM. I can't wait to try other pies from The Pie Hole.
Best-kept secret no longer, huh ;) Glad you found us, Hastey!
Wayne Tanaka said:
The Pie Hole - Pecan and Apple Pies
We had ordered the two pies for a special birthday and Thanksgiving Day treat. We all really enjoyed the pies and would definitely order them again.
That's wonderful to hear, Wayne. Thanks so much :)
Best Guilty pleasure
We absolutely love the Pie hole, once you've tried one you are addicted to this place. The crust is perfection, and every pie is amazing. You feel the love in every bite, no wonder this place is always so busy. Worth every penny.
Keep up the good work 👏
Thank you so much for the support, Melanie! Appreciation like this means the world. Cheers!
Kristin Regan said:
Seriously necessary dinner addition!!! Thank you!!
haha excellent. You are so welcome Kristin :)
This pie is just wonderful...chock full of pecans, it's not too sweet (as most pecan pies are), and is wonderful with evaporated milk (yes, prairie girl here- try it, better than whipped cream). It didn't last that long as it just disappeared.
Hey, whatever suits your pie fancy is ok by me :) Thanks for the review, Kirsty!
lynda hayek said:
it was the best pie we’ve ever had
can’t wait to keep trying new ones
it was my daughters boyfriends birthday and he was over the moon
Wonderful! Happy birthday to moon boy ;P Thanks for the review, Lynda.
Ada leong said:
Got the butter pecan pie and Vietnamese coffee pie. They are amazing!!
Ooo good choices. Thanks so much Ada :)
Had this as a tart, went back for the pie… 9” all to myself! I have never been so happy to have friends with nut allergies. Delicious! I’ll be back very soon 🥰
haha 'Sorry guys. I know we've been friends forever but I found this place called The Pie Hole and...well...unless you have a nut allergy, I don't know you anymore.' That Butter Pecan Pie, what a heartbreaker. Thanks Alice ;)
Leo Eutsler said:
Jenell's Butter Pecan Pie is excellent. It's as good as what my wife used to bake when my uncle would send us fresh pecans from the family's trees in south Georgia. Jenell's pie is thicker than any I've seen and that's a good thing. My pie's only imperfection was a couple inches of missing crust in one area of the rim. We took that to be a manifestation of the handmade nature of the pie.
Thanks Leo! I am also not a big fan of the sugar pie with two pecans in it calling itself pecan pie ;P Gotta walk the walk!
Marci Hammer said:
It was very tasty but it stuck to the foil pan and the crust to filling ratio was crust heavy
Thank you for the feedback, Marci :)
Kendrie Upton said:
Unbelievably delicious, fresh… Fantastic!
Excellent! Thanks so much, Kendrie :)
Linds Mack said:
Best Pecan Pie
Oh man, I dream of the day I can get my hands on my next Butter Pecan Pie from the Pie Hole...! The crust was soooo flakey and buttery, and the filling was beautiful - substantial thickness, not too sweet (which is something for a filling that is mostly sugar!), and the pecans were plentiful and candied to perfection. Ohmygod it was so good.
Stuffin pie holes one dream at a time ;) Thanks so much, Linds!
Debra Walker said:
Butter tart meets pecan pie
This pie was a lovely surprise in that the outside looked like a regular pecan pie but the inside was like the best butter tart ever!!!! gooey, oozy deliciousness!
The best kind ;) Thanks Debra.
Sharon Ohlsen said:
Having recently discovered the Pie Hole and having tried a couple, including the Blueberry Goat Cheese Basil Pie & the Butter Pecan Pie, we now have a desire to potentially work our way through their menu! We love them. Up next, the Pink Lemonade Pie!
haha and so the menu-journey begins! Thanks, Sharon, and enjoy :)
Tai vuong said:
Just a tad too sweet
Overall the pie taste great but the it’s a tad on the sweet side. If the sweetness was toned down a tad, then this would be way better. This pie goes well with ice cream but the double sweetness from the ice cream and the pie is a bit much. I’m on the fence about buying this pie again unless it’s less sweet.
Thanks so much for the feedback, Tai :)
Deb Hong said:
Butter pecan pie
Pecan pie is my dad’s favourite so every year I get this one for his birthday and he loves it!
Thanks Deb! Appreciate the review (and happy birthday to your dad :)
Sinead Gallagher said:
Butter Pecan Tart Review
Went with the butter pecan Tart for our first pie from pie hole and wow!! Flaky pastry with a rich buttery filling, we will be back!
Perfect! Thanks so much, Sinead :)
Sweet but not too sweet, crisp but never dry, with alternating smooth and crunchy mouthfeel each bite. This is the pecan pie I always wanted.
Aw wow! That's so nice to hear! Thanks a bunch, Melissa :)
Jasmine McGregor said:
Butter Pecan deliciousness!
This pie was incredible. Flaky, buttery crust, the pecans must have been pre-toasted because they were crispy and perfect, and the filling was sweet without being excessive. I also picked up a whoopie pie and a rice krispie Square while I was instore-- the whoopie pie barely made it home and the krispie Square was pumpkin spice, cinnamon and delicious
Awesome! Everyone got a little love in that one! Appreciate the review, Jasmine :)
Butter pecan pie
Very yummy but a tad bit too sweet for my tastebuds. My husband loved it.
Everyone's got a different sweet-o-meter, that's for sure. Thanks for the review, C :)
At first I didn’t think I would like the filling texture or it would be too sweet but it was perfect. I want to get it again but must continue to try more as they never cease to amaze me with how delicious they are!
Nothing wrong with having your favourites AND trying new flavours! Thanks for the review, Shante :)
Rachel P said:
Always a treat
Very happy with the divine Butter Pecan Pie we pre-ordered to serve at my household's Christmas dinner.
Crust & filling & pecan topping were perfect. Heated up, and served with vanilla ice cream, it was perfect.
Good online pre-order experience, happy with pickup procedures and attention to Covid awareness and procedures.
Looking forward to our next pie, hopefully soon!
Glad to hear it was a good experience all around, Rachel! Thanks for the review. We'll be here the next time you need us ;)
Jessica Demesa said:
Thanks Jessica :)
Radu Pop said:
Good clean ingredients but taste doesn't wow. Still 4 stars for the Pecan Pie
Thanks for the feedback, Radu :)
Butter Pecan Delight!
Another perfect pie. Crust was wonderful as always!! The filling was an ooey gooey, pecan crunchy delicious mess. Added vanilla ice cream and even more caramel sauce (which isn't needed but why not?). Perfection!!
This game ain't about 'need', kiddo. You done right :) Thanks for the review, Charlene.
Pie was a bit marred by a gigantic crust bubble which displaced some filling but altogether was delicious with a nice note of bourbon!
Sorry for the bubble, Jon! We try to burp our gooey babies, but sometimes one slips through. Glad you enjoyed it all the same :)
Jill Masters said:
Thanks Jill :)
kari Stout said:
Delicious and yummy
Great tasting pie. Not too sweet and buttery. Had pecan and pumpkin and both were Good. Bigger pie is a better deal as 5 inch is more 1 or 2 person.
Awesome! Glad you liked it, Kari. Thanks for the review :)
Courtney Gregory said:
Delicious and well liked
This is my first time ordering and we enjoyed the pie a lot. Will order again soon. Wish I ordered a larger size. Yum
Nothing wrong with starting small...but now it's big pie time!! haha Thanks for the review, Courtney
Stella S said:
Great pie. Not too sweet and great flavour. Everyone at Thanksgiving enjoyed!
And thus, the table was pleased! Thanks so much for the review, Stella :)
Jonathan To said:
Brought this to a family dinner and everyone loved it. Only disappointing thing is there weren't any leftovers :(
*sigh* I know. The best things never last! Good that we're always here to top you up ;) Thanks for the review Jonathan.
The best crust anywhere!!! Fillings not too bad either ;)
Thanks Zippy. We try to make them delicious inside and out :)
Michael Abley said:
Butter Pecan Pie Delicious
I ordered a 9inch butter pecan pie for pick up on a Saturday. I put the order in on a Monday or Tuesday. I picked up the pie no problem, very quick. The pie is excellent, made and cooked to perfection. With three people it only lasted 2 days! We will need to get another pie very soon.
haha The best and worst part of delicious pies, am I right? You're welcome back anytime, Michael :)
Rosemarie Ang said:
very delicious and will try other pies.
Thanks Rosemarie :)
We love the Pie Hole pies! We recently had the butter pecan pie. The crust is buttery and flaky and it was filled to the brim! Love that different sizes are offered too so we can try new pies without committing to a full size pie.
For sure! Gotta make sure it's awesome before you commit. But then you learn how good it is and the flood gates open! Thanks for the review, Susan :)
A good pie, not filled with ‘goop'
I’m never sure what the goop is that super market store pies seem to mostly consist of, much better to get a Pie Hole pie that is actually filled with pecans.
Our bakery is definitely full of adorable nuts...and pecans ;) Thanks so much Allan.
Thanks Ling :)
Kam Johal said:
Butter Pecan Pie
This pie is delicious! Classic flavour with the perfect crunch of pecans, will definitely repurchase again. One of many pies that have been a hit with our family from the Pie Hole - thanks!
Great to hear Kam! Glad you guys liked it :)
David Antonio said:
These Pies are no Lies
Pecan Pie. Goes great with Tea, Coffee, or even Aviation Gin.
Hey, whatever floats your boat/plane :) Thanks David
We are so happy to be able to order from the Pie Hole again. We have tried many of their pies and are never disappointed. I can’t even tell you which are our favourites as they are all absolutely delicious!
The sweet pies are such a wonderful treat and the savoury pies are such an easy way to have a tasty dinner and the best leftovers. I would love to see a vegetarian vegetable pot pie, will cross my fingers.
Hmm...we are always considering new flavour options... Thanks for the awesome review Alicia :)
Excellent pies, as always. I can see why the butter pecan is a staff favourite. We tried the Vegan Pumpkin Pie (as they had run out of regular) and it was satisfactory even without the butter. Perhaps have some extra regular pumpkin pies on American Thanksgiving next year though ☺️
Thanks for the review, Coleen. Glad the pies hit the mark ;)
Yummy and not too sweet
Ordered a pecan pie and apple caramel praline pie - both were so good! Not too sweet!
Awesome Celina! So glad the pies could walk the sweet line for you ;)
Pamela Swanton said:
Amazing Butter Pecan Pie!!
I ordered the Butter Pecan Pie for Thanksgiving after tasting a Butter Pecan Tart in the store. Soooooo good! My family loved the pie! We are now replacing birthday cake with birthday pie from The Pie Hole :)
Wow Pamela! Replacing birthday cake with our pies has to be one of the greatest compliments. I am ecstatic and flattered :) The Pie Hole family and the Swanton family are now officially joined!! Don't be a stranger!
Kelly Kuit said:
We ordered the pumpkin pie and pecan pie. They were amazing, so much flavour without being too sweet. The crust is unbelievable perfectly flakey without being dry.
Superb, Kelly! I am so glad your pies hit the mark!! You come back anytime :)
Anastasia Tsonis said:
Norman Petkau said:
So many nuts!
If you like a butter pecan loaded with nuts this is the pie! Personally I like a little more of the buttery sweetness (and less nuts). Quality pie with delicious crust.
Thanks for the comment, Norman. It's true, our Butter Pecan Pie is a little...nutty. Seriously though, nut-to-filling ratio is an oddly particular thing for all pie-lovers (our bakers will never agree on the 'perfect' balance). Thanks for appreciating our pie all the same!
Luke Takeuchi said:
Bought a bunch of pies for Thanksgiving including this Butter Pecan Pie and they were amazing. I would 100% re-order the Pecan Pie, this is now one of my go-tos from Pie Hole.
Thank you Luke!
Butter pecan pie
It’s definitely one of their best pies! Ordered the 5 inch, it was so good I had to get the 9”. It’s that good!
Thank you for the great review!
Perfect for birthday surprises!
Delicious crust that stayed fresh for 3 days (no idea how that pie lasted that long). I had to buy the pie the night before my husband’s birthday and was a bit worried it won’t age as well but it tasted just as good! Thanks!
Thanks for the positive review Kathy. Because we don't use any preservatives, shortening or lard in our cooking, we don't recommend keeping the pies much longer than that - however they will usually last for 3-4 days no problem. We do recommend eating them the first minute you get them though ;-)
Your pie is so good my friend requested I bring one to Victoria for her husband's birthday. It was a hit. :)
Thank you for the review... so nice to hear that people from afar want our pies! perhaps one day we'll have a store in Victoria...
This pecan pie is the absolute best! Such a perfect amount of pecans and filling - yum : )
Thank you for the great review.
PHYLLIS MCCONNACHIE said:
I served it to my guests and they loved it.