"To Die For" Banana Cream Pie


"To Die For" Banana Cream Pie

This aptly named pie not only because it is the best banana cream ever but it is also topped with housemade caramel sauce and locally made "To Die For" Banana Bread.





3" (6-Pack)


3" Individual
Generally our 9 inch pies serve 8 hungry folks. The 5 inch pies are just right for two pie-eating lovebirds.

All our prices include tax, so no surprises!


  • Banana

  • Cream

  • Peanut Butter

  • Chocolate

Bananas, Milk, Cream, Flour, Butter, Sugar, Brown Sugar, Free Run Eggs, Cornstarch, "To Die For" Banana Bread (Contains Macademia Nuts), Vanilla, Icing Sugar, Cream Stabilizer, Vinegar, Water, Salt

Ordering Details

This pie must be ordered with 48 hours notice. It will be ready at our store within 48 hours (or longer if you'd like to order well in advance). Please give us a call if you have any questions.

If you're still not sure about this whole "internet" thing and you would prefer to shop for your pie in person, you can find a retailer here